Shubman Gill’s DRS Nightmare: India Lose All Three Reviews Against New Zealand

1

Shubman Gill’s DRS Decisions Under Fire as India Waste Three Reviews Against New Zealand

India captain Shubman Gill endured a difficult outing with the Decision Review System (DRS) during the opening two days of the first Test against New Zealand at Wellington’s Basin Reserve. All three reviews taken by India during the period proved unsuccessful, with Gill making the final call on each occasion.

The situation became even more frustrating for India as Gill also missed an opportunity to challenge a clear caught-behind decision against Rachin Ravindra on the opening day. Despite strong appeals from wicketkeeper Rishabh Pant and the slip fielders, the skipper opted against reviewing the decision.

Gill’s latest DRS struggles have added to concerns over his judgement while leading India’s Test side. Statistics released in August 2026 indicated that he had called for 41 reviews as captain, with only five resulting in successful overturns. The three failed attempts in Wellington further extended that disappointing record.

FIRST REVIEW ENDS IN DISAPPOINTMENT

India’s first unsuccessful review came during Glenn Phillips’ stay at the crease on Day 1. Jasprit Bumrah delivered a ball that came back sharply and went past the New Zealand batter’s bat. India’s players appealed for LBW, but the on-field umpire remained unmoved.

Bumrah appeared doubtful about the delivery’s height and reportedly cautioned Gill against reviewing the decision. However, the Indian captain felt Phillips had not made contact with the ball and decided to challenge the umpire’s call.

The Snickometer detected a spike as the ball passed the bat. Although the initial front-on footage was inconclusive, further examination in slow motion convinced third umpire Paul Reiffel that there had been a slight deflection. The original not-out decision was therefore upheld.

Gill was visibly dissatisfied and attempted to explain his interpretation of the incident to umpire Richard Illingworth. His argument was that there was sufficient separation between bat and ball and that the delivery had struck Phillips’ back pad first. India had nevertheless lost their first review.

MISSED OPPORTUNITY TO DISMISS RACHIN RAVINDRA

India’s biggest DRS blunder on the opening day came when Anshul Kamboj found the outside edge of Rachin Ravindra’s bat with the new ball.

Rishabh Pant completed a clean catch behind the stumps, but the on-field umpire rejected India’s appeal. Pant and the fielders in the slip cordon immediately encouraged Gill to review the decision.

The captain, however, chose not to challenge the call, allowing the review countdown to expire. Subsequent UltraEdge footage revealed a clear spike as the ball passed the bat, indicating that Ravindra would likely have been given out had India reviewed.

The left-hander capitalised on the reprieve, facing another 50 deliveries before Akash Deep eventually dismissed him caught behind. Kamboj had earlier provided India with an important breakthrough by removing Devon Conway, leaving New Zealand struggling at 12/2.

TWO MORE REVIEWS GO WRONG ON DAY 2

India’s DRS problems continued on the second day, with Akash Deep becoming involved in both unsuccessful appeals.

The first incident involved Nathan Smith, who was struck on the pads by a delivery that moved back sharply. India appealed for LBW, but umpire Kumar Dharmasena turned down the request.

Akash Deep had doubts about whether the delivery was travelling too high. Gill nevertheless decided to review the decision. Ball-tracking subsequently showed that the ball would have passed over the stumps, confirming the umpire’s original call.

With two reviews already wasted, India had just one remaining opportunity.

The final review came against Matt Henry, who faced a short delivery from Akash Deep. The batter moved away from the ball and appeared to keep his hands clear. Neither the bowler nor Pant showed much interest in appealing, but Gill, positioned at first slip, believed there had been an edge.

He immediately called for a review. The replays, however, showed a visible gap between the bat and the ball, while the Snickometer registered no spike. India’s third review was gone, leaving Gill with an awkward smile. Henry appeared equally amused by the situation.

India later faced another LBW appeal against Kyle Jamieson, but this time decided not to review it. Prasidh Krishna had beaten the batter with a delivery that moved back, although ball-tracking suggested it was sailing over the stumps. The decision not to challenge proved to be the correct one.

NICHOLLS AND PHILLIPS TURN THE GAME AROUND

India’s disappointing use of DRS was particularly costly given how well their bowling attack had started the innings.

New Zealand were reduced to 70/5, putting India in a strong position to take control. However, Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips produced a remarkable counterattack, stitching together a partnership worth more than 200 runs.

Phillips scored an impressive 118 before Akash Deep finally ended the partnership on Day 2. After repeatedly bowling from wide of the crease, the pacer changed his angle and came closer to the stumps, eventually producing a delivery that beat Phillips’ outside edge.

Nicholls continued his resistance and remained unbeaten on 175 as New Zealand were dismissed for 368 in 121 overs.

India managed to claim the remaining four wickets for just 51 runs after lunch. Bumrah led the attack with four wickets for 92 runs, while Akash Deep finished with three for 53. Prasidh Krishna also picked up a wicket, with Kamboj accounting for the final dismissal.

Nicholls received a standing ovation from the Basin Reserve spectators as he walked back to the pavilion. Gill congratulated the New Zealand batter with a handshake, while his family joined the crowd in applauding the impressive innings.

While India’s bowlers eventually managed to restrict New Zealand to 368, Gill’s questionable review decisions remained one of the major talking points from the opening two days.

Comments are closed.